The key to any team sport is teamwork and cooperation. However, in almost any sport you read or hear about these days, there is a focus on individual talent and achievement. I think a lot of it is driven by professional sports and the amount of money that gets thrown around to individual players. While I'll admit that I go to sporting events and support professional athletes indirectly by attending games, I find the amount of money the athletes make completely insane for their relative importance in society. At the end of the day, it's a game. That's it. Too many times, we lose perspective on that. I digress...
I was reminded of what makes sports great when I watched the Trailblazers play the Lakers last night. When talking about the Lakers, the announcers talked about how Kobe had to take over the game to bring the Lakers back from a huge deficit. However, the same was not mentioned about the Trailblazers. There was more of a focus on what the team needed to do, not individual players. Rudy Fernandez was injured by a flagrant foul late in the game, and all of the Trailblazers came to his defense to protect their teammate. After the game, they interviewed Joel Pryzbilla, who had a fantastic game. When they asked him about his effort, he always deferred to the team and how his teammates helped him, and he was just trying to contribute. Then, this evening, while reading the sports section of the newspaper, there was an article on the game where there was a discussion about how team oriented the Trailblazers are along with quotes from different players about how committed they are to each other. While you could argue that Brandon Roy is the star player, every player on the team knows and accepts their role, and does what's in the best interest of the team. This is what teamwork is all about. I'll take the entire Trailblazer team over Kobe Bryant any day.
Enough about basketball. However, I had to review that as it's relevant to today's topic.
When I played sports, I experience both good and bad teams. It was especially evident in high school sports where star players were given special treatment over the rest of the team. Anything to win. Everyone on the team knew there was a pecking order, and it really caused a lot of friction to the point where true teamwork was close to impossible to achieve. I did have one experience playing high school baseball where we were immensely successful all 4 years. While we had some star players, the coach treated everyone the same, and placed just as much importance on the last player on the bench as he did his best player. Respect was given to all players, and no individual player got special treatment. We all had roles, we understood them, and we worked within our individual roles to make the team better. Even though baseball was not my primary sport, it's the background I draw from the most in my coaching philosophy.
I think one of the most difficult things to do for most coaches is to enforce the rules when they are broken by a star or key player on the team. With the pressure and emphasis our society places on winning, it's tough not to give into the pressure. However, I have much more respect for coaches that enforce the rules evenly, even though it may cost the team a much needed victory in a key situation. Coaches that give into the pressure are the norm today, and that's a sad fact. It doesn't teach our players the valuable lessons they will need later on in life.
I'm very honest that I've made my mistakes in this area. I haven't always made the right choice, and I chose to ignore things I shouldn't have ignored. However, I have learned some lessons along the way, and have become much more comfortable making the tough decisions. Maybe it's from experience or maybe it's just that I'm old enough to understand that winning at any cost just isn't as important as building responsible young people, which is ultimately what coaching should be about. I would like to share some stories that help to emphasize the point.
The first situation was when I coached a young boys team, and was one of my bigger mistakes as a coach, and my best learning experience. On this team, I had a pretty interesting demographic mix. I had "richer" kids from one town mixed with kids from "working class" families from another town. There was constant conflict on the team, and a lot of it centered around the economic differences. At one point, one of the boys from one of the "working class" families made it a habit of picking on one of the kids from one of the "richer" families. It really got out of hand, and I finally approached the kid who was picking on the other. It lead to a discussion with his parents, and eventually an apology to me. However, I should have done better. I never asked him to apologize to the other kid, and I never took any disciplinary action as far as playing time, etc. It was a huge mistake as even though I had "taken care of" the incident, nothing was settled between the players, and there continued to be a division in the team. We did end up winning President's Cup. How, I don't know. We managed to put our differences aside on the field when we needed to. However, to this day, I always look at that situation as one that I should have done better. As a result, I handled things differently, and better in two other situations.
A couple of years later, I had a similar situation that I had to deal with. The team had a more diverse group of family situations, but I had two players that were not getting along. They were both defenders, which is a pretty key area to have two players not getting along. For some reason, one player felt the need to constantly tease the other player. I was determined to handle this situation much differently. To complicate matters, the player doing the teasing was the daughter of one of the board members of the soccer club. I started out with warnings to the whole team, along with a discussion with the parents to re-enforce. I made it very clear at our first team meeting that I didn't have many rules, and that the one thing I would come down hard on was dissent between players. They didn't have to like each other, but when we were together, they would treat each other with respect. Unfortunately, the teasing and behavior continued. After the warning, I contacted the parents to let them know what was going on, and what I planned about doing on it. Response from a parent in that situation is not very predictable these days, so I set my expectations low, but I made it clear that whether they liked it or not, I was going to do what needed to be done. To their credit, the parents supported my decision and actions. It was a huge relief for me that helped me deal with the situation much more easily.
What happened, you ask? After talking to the parents, and informing them what would happen and when, I talked to the player doing the teasing. I reminded her of the rules of the team, and the prior warnings. To her credit, while she was very upset about the situation, she acknowledged her actions, and accepted her punishment. Her punishment was to sit out the first half of the next game, and she knew if the behavior continued, there would be additional suspension of playing time, possibly through the end of the season. What made this situation difficult is that she was one of my key central defenders, and we were playing an important game that would help determine our standing for the playoff tournament, and we were playing the game with no subs and players playing out of position. We did manage to win the game, and I found that the rest of their teammates rallied around the two players, and they all worked together to find a way to get along and maintain a high level of teamwork. It also sent a message to the rest of the team that no one player was greater than the health of the team. It was a difficult week for me, personally, but was a great success for the team.
Similar situations happened with a high school boys team this past year that I was an assistant coach at. I agreed to help another coach I have worked with in the past with the high school team. I agreed because we work well together, and we have the same philosophy when it comes to work ethic, teamwork, etc. The prior coach of this team had some pretty lax rules, there was a clear pecking order within the team, and players felt they could do what they wanted when they wanted. The team did have quite a bit of talent, but it took quite a bit of effort and headaches to turn things around.
We had some players that were quite talented, and were used to being treated like royalty. We had several situations where we had to discipline players for behavior detrimental to the team, including players that had been playing on the varsity soccer team since their freshman year in high school. This was a tough group, but we did manage to pull things together to make it to the playoffs, and lost in the second round in double overtime to the eventual state runner up. Here are some of the things we handled and how we handled them. Did we do everything right and catch everything that happened? No. Did we turn things around? Yes. Did we set the tone for years to come? Yes.
There was one player that decided he could openly question our coaching decisions in front of the rest of the team, and in the process, insult his teammates. At the time, we were playing in a small series of scrimmages throughout the day. After the incident, we benched him for the remainder of the day. He was a key player, but everyone had to understand that no one was above the rules. There was quite a bit of shock amongst his teammates when we not only talked about the rules, but enforced them. We did have another incident with the same player later in the season, and had to bench him for a league game, which could have had a huge impact on making the playoffs. The team managed to rally to a tie during a difficult game, and we had no further incidents with this player. Over time, he came to understand what we expected, and began to make an effort to improve his communication with his teammates. It's still a work in progress, but it's headed in the right direction.
We had another player that had a serious attitude and work ethic problem. He had been a varsity starter since his freshman year, and clearly felt he was above everyone else. We had heard from many different coaches that this player was hostile towards and argumentative with coaches. We made several attempts to reach this player by explaining what we needed from him, and what was expected. His behavior continued regardless of what we tried. We eventually dropped him to the JV team, which would have been a first. In his first game on the JV team, the JV team was playing on a field next to the varsity team. When the other team scored a goal on us, he cheered for the opposing team. He was reprimanded by the JV coach, and never returned to the program. The interesting thing is that he will be a senior next year, and whether he understands it or not, we remember what happened last year. While we will give him a chance to redeem himself, his behavior must improve. Neither the head coach nor I will accept anything less than good attitude and behavior. He could be a valuable contributor to the team, but will not unless he adheres to the rules and standards we set.
The last situation was one involving one of our seniors. He had played varsity soccer since his freshman year, and had three years under the previous coach. I would say it's difficult for both the coach and player in this situation. After three years of one coach, and then comes another coaching staff his final year where things are changed. It's not easy for anyone involved. Anyway, one of the habits that members of the team had from the previous years was having "injuries" when they didn't feel like practicing. First, we set the rules where if you didn't practice the day before a game, you didn't play. However, the players would take advantage of the situation when there were more than one practice between games.
In the situation in question, we had just finished a tough game against our rival school where we pulled out a victory. It was a rough and physical game. The senior came to practice the next day and said bluntly that he was too sore from the game to practice. He had obviously thought about this in advance as he didn't even have his clothes for practice. The head coach sent him home, made him get soccer clothes, and when he returned to practice, he spent the entire practice running while the rest of the team practiced. It was a difficult situation, but it sent a good message to both the player and the team. The player was upset and didn't talk to us for a while after that. But, we also didn't have any more mysterious injury problems for the remainder of the season.
As usual, this has been a long entry, but I think the examples help to re-enforce the point. When the individuals become more important than the team, the team fails. It takes a lot of courage and determination for the coach to consistently enforce rules and policies, but when it's all said and done, those are life lessons that the players will remember long after the wins and losses are forgotten.